/columns/around-the-nation/2014/snap-judgments-week-6

Snap judgments: Putting the -ack in ODAC

On Saturday afternoon, D3football.com publisher Pat Coleman sent this tweet to me and Around the Mid-Atlantic columnist Adam Turer.

The Wasps have added to the unpredictability of this year's ODAC by starting off 5-0.
Emory and Henry athletics file photo

The answer, of course, is yes. If you scoured the scoreboard or saw the recaps on the front page of D3football.com, you’d know what prompted the question. First off, Shenandoah won its first conference game of the season, and it came over the top of Guilford, a team that was strongly expected to compete for the conference championship. It’s hard to call this shocking after watching Shenandoah last year edge out Hampden-Sydney to deal the Tigers their only conference loss of the season. The Hornets seem to have found themselves in a comfortable spoiler role in the Old Dominion.

The quirk with “ODACtion” is that one-loss teams aren’t out of the running this early in conference play. Those who have been around D-III for a while might remember 2008, when the ODAC had four teams tied with 4-2 conference record (that year’s automatic qualifier team, Randolph-Macon, was “rewarded” with a trip to Mount Union).

Couple this with this season’s unexpected runs from Bridgewater and Emory and Henry, and this conference could justifiably be called the king of parity.

Who would be the parity prince? I’m sure the argument could be made for a few conferences.

  • The Centennial has had many years of parity dating back to at least 2004, when it had five of its seven teams tied at 4-2 in conference play (Muhlenberg fell at the hands of St. John Fisher that year in the playoffs). Johns Hopkins has ruled the roost over the past few years, but subsequent spots have seen Muhlenberg, Ursinus, Gettysburg and Moravian all up there – and that doesn’t even count the newfound competitiveness from former perennial zero- and one-win Juniata.
  • This year’s Empire 8 would be a good candidate, with all but one team already having a conference win and the development of head-to-head-to-head victory triangles emerging – Alfred beat Buffalo State who beat Ithaca who beat Alfred. To keep with the flashbacks, the E8’s history of parity was probably best highlighted in 2007, when it was the only conference in the automatic bid era to send three teams – Harwick, Ithaca and St. John Fisher – to the playoffs.
  • Delaware Valley shook up the MAC race by beating No. 20 Lycoming and is making the Top 25 pollsters re-evaluate where the teams fit in in that conference. The conference may not show the top-to-bottom parity that some of the others mentioned do, but the potential for so many teams each year to snag the AQ makes the MAC a difficult one to pigeon-hole (so much so that it was asked of our expert panel in the preseason Kickoff publication which team would win the MAC. I had picked Lycoming).

What else stood out? Of the nine teams in the Top 10 that played on Saturday, only No. 10 Wabash saw its opponent break into double digits – and that was a mere 13-point outing by Ohio Wesleyan. Moreover, six of those games were shutouts, from a “narrow” 37-0 win by UW-Whitewater to a 62-0 outing by Mount Union, of which perhaps the most notable thing was that Gagliardi Trophy-winner Kevin Burke threw his first interception in 127 attempts dating to last season.

In the Pacific Northwest. The outcome of the NWC game between Willamette and Whitworth caught me off guard. A week after losing to a questionable Pacific team, Whitworth drops a 61-45 bomb on Willamette behind a 389-yard, four-touchdown game from quarterback Bryan Peterson and a 141-yard, three-score game from rusher Duke Degaetano. Willamette, undefeated before this week, was No. 25 on my ballot. Barring a win over Linfield and/or Pacific Lutheran, it’s unlikely the Bearcats will jump back on there again this season.

Hendrix crashes. The second-season Cinderella run of Hendrix came to a stifling halt at the hands of Washington U. The Bears gave Berry its first win in the modern era last week and appeared reluctant to let their faults manifest themselves again this week. Wash U. had a 45-10 lead going into the half.

On my radar. In this past week’s Triple Take, one thing I said I was looking forward to seeing was the MIAA matchup between Olivet and Trine. This game did not disappoint. Both teams were at the top of the conference heap, and lucky for us, they played each other early in the season. Not until late in the third-quarter did the teams separate themselves by more than a touchdown, and despite Olivet pulling ahead, Trine roared down the stretch with the final three scores of the game, pulling out the 46-42 win. Each team posted more than 500 yards of offense and lots of standout individual performances.

More living up to the hype. Texas Lutheran scored 41 second-half points to win the blazing showdown with East Texas Baptist 55-49. Remember what I said earlier about Willamette falling off my ballot. TLU earned my vote with Saturday’s performance and will get the 25th spot from me. Marquis Barrolle had 247 yards on the ground for TLU, and ETBU got a standout game from quarterback Josh Warbington with 426 yards through the air and four touchdowns.

A #whyd3 story: Looking at the tweet below, don’t think some WIAC linemen are getting smaller. Rather, it’s the UW-Stevens Point team working with some of hundreds of players from Youth Area Football teams. UW-SP has been holding “Practice with the Pointers” since 2008.

More features

November 12, 2025 New pieces fit for Gulls Many Division III football playoff contenders lost significant portions of their team to graduation this past year. At...
November 12, 2025 Reloading Whitworth recovers from slow start The Pirates made the second round of the playoffs but was another program that bid farewell to a bunch of seniors -- 33, in...
November 5, 2025 Roanoke making most of its first season The Maroons hadn't played a varsity football game since 1942, and no matter what expectations one might have had for Roanoke...
November 4, 2025 Hanover eyes a November to remember The Panthers have already secured the HCAC's automatic bid to the playoffs, but there are two games left, including a huge...
October 29, 2025 Curtis's message: Keep fighting Carleton quarterback Jack Curtis has been receiving chemo treatment at the famed Mayo Clinic every Monday. It takes him until...
October 29, 2025 LaGrange in control of its destiny For a team which won nine games over the course of five seasons, being in control of its own destiny entering November is a...
October 29, 2025 Rowan not giving up The Profs came within a score of defeating two outstanding teams but find themselves on the wrong side of the math at the...
October 22, 2025 Blocking for Mr. 522 No running back can gain 522 yards in a single game without an offensive line that is up to the task, and Montie Quinn owes...
October 22, 2025 D-III drama in the dimming daylight John Carroll and DePauw squared off in a memorable game that ended with the last daylight of Saturday, after waiting out a...
October 15, 2025 Norton perseveres in making lives better Fifteen years ago, Luther football player Chris Norton was paralyzed in an on-field injury, and was given little chance of...

Greg Thomas

Greg Thomas graduated in 2000 from Wabash College. He has contributed to D3football.com since 2014 as a bracketologist, Kickoff writer, curator of Quick Hits, and Around The Nation Podcast guest host before taking co-host duties over in 2021. Greg lives in Claremont, California.

Previous columnists:
2016-2019: Adam Turer.
2014-2015: Ryan Tipps.
2001-2013: Keith McMillan.

Other Columnists